Procedure of Supreme Court of India

Supreme Court Practice: What is the procedure of Supreme Court?

The procedure of the Supreme Court can vary depending on the type of case being heard and the jurisdiction in which it is being heard. However, here’s a general overview of the procedure typically followed in the United States Supreme Court:

Handbook on Practice and Procedure

handbook-on-practice-and-procedureDownload

1. Filing of Petition:
   • The party seeking review files a petition for a writ of certiorari, asking the Supreme Court to review the decision of a lower court.
   • The petition outlines the legal questions at issue and argues why the Supreme Court should agree to hear the case.
2. Response and Briefing:
   • The opposing party may file a response to the petition, arguing why the Supreme Court should not hear the case.
   • If the Court grants certiorari (agrees to hear the case), the parties submit briefs outlining their legal arguments and supporting evidence.
3. Oral Arguments:
   • The Court schedules oral arguments, during which each side has a limited amount of time (typically 30 minutes) to present their case and answer questions from the justices.
4. Deliberation and Opinion Writing:
   • After oral arguments, the justices meet in conference to discuss the case and cast preliminary votes.
   • The justice assigned to write the majority opinion drafts the opinion, which is circulated among the justices for review and comment.
5. Opinion Announcement:
   • Once a majority of the justices agree on the outcome and reasoning, the opinion is announced in open court.
   • Justices may also write concurring or dissenting opinions, expressing agreement or disagreement with the majority’s reasoning.
6. Enforcement of Decision:
   • The Supreme Court’s decision is final and binding on the parties involved.
   • Lower courts and government agencies are required to follow the Supreme Court’s interpretation of the law.

It’s important to note that this is a simplified overview, and the actual process can be more complex, especially in high-profile cases or cases involving novel legal issues. Additionally, procedures may differ in other countries with their own supreme courts.

The United States Supreme Court follows a specific set of procedures to ensure the efficient and fair handling of cases. Here is a general outline of the procedure:

1. Petition for Certiorari: A party who wants their case to be heard by the Supreme Court must file a petition for a writ of certiorari. This is a request for the Court to review the decision of a lower court. The Supreme Court receives thousands of petitions each year but only grants a small percentage of them.
2. Conference: The justices meet in private conferences to discuss the petitions and decide which cases to accept. A case is granted certiorari if at least four justices agree to hear it.
3. Briefing: Once a case is accepted, both parties submit written briefs to the Court. These briefs outline the legal arguments and relevant case law supporting their positions. Amicus curiae briefs from interested third parties may also be submitted.
4. Oral Arguments: In most cases, the Court will schedule oral arguments. Attorneys for both parties present their arguments and answer questions from the justices. Each side usually has 30 minutes to present their case.
5. Conference and Decision: After oral arguments, the justices meet in conference to discuss the case and vote on the outcome. The majority opinion, concurring opinions, and dissenting opinions are drafted and circulated among the justices for comments and revisions.
6. Announcement of Decision: The Court announces its decisions in open court, and the opinions are made public. The outcome of the case sets a legal precedent that lower courts must follow in similar cases.

This procedure ensures that the Supreme Court carefully selects the cases it hears and thoroughly considers the legal issues involved. The process allows for both parties to present their arguments and for the justices to deliberate and reach a decision that shapes the interpretation and application of the law.

The Supreme Court of India follows a specific procedure for handling cases, which can be broadly categorized into these stages:

1. Filing and Jurisdiction:

• Only advocates authorized by the Supreme Court can file cases.
• The Supreme Court primarily deals with appeals from lower courts, but it also has original jurisdiction in specific cases.

2. Types of Cases:

• Appeals can be filed under various articles of the Constitution, like substantial questions of law or constitutional interpretation.
• There are different categories of cases, including civil appeals, criminal appeals, writ petitions, and more.

3. Benches and Hearings:

• The Chief Justice determines the composition of benches (single, division, or constitution) based on the case complexity.
• During hearings, advocates for both parties present their arguments before the judges.

4. Judgments and Orders:

• After deliberation, the Court issues a judgment or order, which may uphold the lower court’s decision, overturn it, or provide further instructions.

Resources for further details:

• You can find the Supreme Court Rules, 2013 for a more comprehensive understanding of procedures.
• The Supreme Court of India website also has a handbook on practice and procedure.

Remember, this is a general overview, and the specifics of procedure may vary depending on the nature of the case.

Supreme Court Practice: What is the procedure of Supreme Court of India?

The procedure of the Supreme Court of India generally follows these steps:

1. Filing of Petition:
   • The process typically begins with the filing of a Special Leave Petition (SLP) in the Supreme Court.
   • An SLP is filed to seek special permission from the Supreme Court to appeal against a decision of a lower court or tribunal.
2. Admission or Rejection of Petition:
   • The Supreme Court may admit the SLP for hearing if it involves a substantial question of law or a matter of public importance.
   • If the Court is satisfied with the grounds raised in the petition, it may grant permission for the appeal to be heard.
3. Exchange of Pleadings and Documents:
   • After the admission of the petition, the parties exchange pleadings and documents.
   • This includes the filing of written submissions, rejoinders, affidavits, and other relevant documents supporting their case.
4. Oral Arguments:
   • The Supreme Court schedules a date for oral arguments, during which advocates representing each party present their arguments before the bench.
   • Justices may ask questions or seek clarifications from the advocates during the oral arguments.
5. Deliberation and Judgment:
   • After considering the arguments presented by both parties, the Supreme Court bench deliberates on the case.
   • The Court then pronounces its judgment, either affirming, modifying, or reversing the decision of the lower court or tribunal.
6. Enforcement of Decision:
   • The decision of the Supreme Court is binding on all parties involved.
   • Lower courts and authorities are required to comply with the Supreme Court’s orders and judgments.

It’s important to note that the Supreme Court of India has original jurisdiction in certain cases, such as disputes between the Union and the States or between States themselves, as well as appellate jurisdiction over decisions of High Courts and other tribunals. The specific procedure may vary depending on the nature of the case and the jurisdiction of the Supreme Court.

The Supreme Court of India follows a specific set of procedures to ensure the efficient and fair handling of cases. Here’s a general outline of the procedure:

1. Filing a Petition: A party who wants their case to be heard by the Supreme Court must file a petition, usually in the form of a Special Leave Petition (SLP), a Writ Petition, or an Appeal.
2. Admission Hearing: The Court conducts an admission hearing to determine whether the petition should be admitted for regular hearing. The Court may issue notice to the respondents and ask for their response.
3. Reply and Rejoinder: The respondents file their counter-affidavits or written statements in response to the petition. The petitioner may then file a rejoinder to address the points raised in the counter-affidavits.
4. Regular Hearing: The case is listed for regular hearing, where the parties present their arguments and evidence before a bench of judges. The bench may consist of two or more judges, depending on the nature and importance of the case.
5. Judgment: After hearing both parties and examining the evidence, the bench delivers its judgment. The judgment may uphold, reverse, or modify the decision of the lower court or tribunal.
6. Review Petition: If a party is aggrieved by the judgment, they may file a Review Petition. Review Petitions are heard in chambers by the same bench that delivered the judgment or, if not available, by a bench of the same strength.
7. Curative Petition: If a party is still aggrieved, they may file a Curative Petition. These petitions are decided by a bench of at least three senior-most judges and the judges who passed the judgment complained of, if available.
8. Appeal to a Larger Bench: In exceptional cases, a party may appeal to a larger bench of the Supreme Court, such as a Constitution Bench consisting of five or more judges.

This procedure ensures that the Supreme Court carefully considers the legal issues involved and delivers well-reasoned judgments that set precedents for lower courts and tribunals. The process allows for multiple stages of review and appeal, providing opportunities for the parties to present their arguments and seek redressal.

The Supreme Court of India adheres to a well-defined procedure for handling cases. Here’s a breakdown of the key steps:

1. Initiation and Jurisdiction:

• Authorized Advocates: Only advocates registered as Advocates-on-Record (AOR) can file cases before the Supreme Court.
• Types of Jurisdiction: The Court primarily handles appeals from lower courts. However, it also has original jurisdiction in specific cases outlined in the Constitution.

2. Filing and Classification:

• The party seeking appeal or judgment files a petition outlining the case details and grounds for seeking intervention from the Supreme Court.
• Petitions are categorized based on their nature – civil appeals, criminal appeals, writ petitions (like Habeas Corpus), etc..

3. Bench Constitution and Hearings:

• The Chief Justice determines the appropriate bench (single judge, division bench, or constitution bench) to hear the case based on its complexity.
• During hearings, advocates for both sides present their arguments before the judges, citing relevant laws and precedents.

4. Judgments and Orders:

• Following deliberation, the Court delivers a judgment or order. This may involve upholding the lower court’s decision, overturning it, or issuing further instructions.

Resources for Further Study:

• For a deeper understanding of procedures, refer to the Supreme Court Rules, 2013.
• The Supreme Court of India website offers a handbook on practice and procedure.

Remember, this is a simplified overview. The specifics of the procedure can vary depending on the case’s nature and the applicable legal provisions.